Breach of Duty in Injury Claims

What is a Breach of Duty?

When a person or entity fails to act in accordance with their obligations, they may be found guilty of breach of duty. This type of misconduct can be considered a civil wrong or criminal offense, depending on the situation. In this post, we’ll explain what constitutes a breach of duty and some consequences that may arise.

Duty of Care

A duty of care is a legal obligation one party has to another, usually arising from a relationship between them. When it comes to personal injury cases, the duty of care requires each party to take reasonable steps to prevent harming others.

For example, doctors are obligated to provide medical care that meets or exceeds an accepted standard of care. Motorists have a responsibility to other drivers on the road to drive safely and adhere to traffic laws. Property owners must maintain their premises in a safe condition for any visitors who may come by.

When these duties of care are breached, serious consequences can result. Failing to meet your obligations can lead to civil litigation or even criminal prosecution, depending on the circumstances. It is thus important to understand your duties when it comes to the safety of others and to make sure you take all possible measures to fulfill those obligations.

Duty of Care & Negligence Claims

Negligence is a concept deeply embedded in the legal system, upon which many personal injury claims are based. Such claims are initiated when someone is injured directly due to another person’s unreasonable actions.

The plaintiff must prove four key elements to be successful in a negligence claim: (1) the defendant owed the plaintiff a duty of care; (2) the defendant breached that duty of care; (3) such breach caused the plaintiff’s injury; and (4) the plaintiff suffered harm or damage as a result. Everyone owes those around them a certain level of care. This holds true even when parties are strangers. For example, when driving on the road, each driver has an obligation to behave as any reasonable person would in the same situation. Failing to do so, and causing others damage as a result, gives rise to a finding of negligence.

A breach of duty occurs whenever an action is deemed unreasonably by the court or jury. This reasonable person standard is an abstract concept that guides such considerations. Further, liability can still attach even where there are multiple causes of an accident, so long as one of those factors remains proximately related to the injury sustained, thereby linking it to the act alleged to have been negligent.

Ultimately, for the plaintiff to receive compensation, they must have suffered some kind of harm, whether in relation to property or person. A claim for damages cannot succeed without proof of injury or damage.

Proving Negligence

Negligence is established when:

  1. A party breaches their duty of care AND
  2. this breach causes harm.

For instance, say a driver exceeds the posted speed limit. In most cases, this would constitute a breach of duty because speeding increases the risk of an accident. However, even if the driver was speeding, this does not guarantee that they are liable for any resulting damage. To demonstrate negligence, you must link the driver’s breach of duty to the cause of the accident. In other words, it must be proven that their actions were directly responsible for your injuries.

If you can link the at-fault driver’s actions to the cause of your accident, you may recover compensation for your damages. It is important to remember that you must provide proof to receive compensation, so make sure to gather all evidence related to the incident.

What Constitutes a Breach of Duty of Care?

A breach of duty occurs when someone fails to fulfill an obligation under law or contract. If an act or omission by a doctor results in injury to the patient, this can be considered a breach of duty of care. In other words, a breach occurs when a patient receives a lower-than-accepted standard of care than expected for their condition or circumstance. Victims of medical malpractice may be able to recover money for related costs such as medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and more. However, determining if a breach occurred can be complex, so seeking experienced legal advice is important before pursuing a case.

In a medical malpractice lawsuit, the plaintiff must demonstrate that the defendant was negligent in providing care by not exercising the level of care, expertise, and knowledge that a reasonable physician in the same or similar circumstance could be expected to provide. Examples of when a medical professional may be found to have breached their duty of care include:

  • failure to diagnose or treat a condition;
  • misdiagnosis or mistreatment of a condition;
  • incorrect dosage of medication;
  • inappropriate use of medical devices;
  • performing unnecessary or unsafe procedures;
  • failure to obtain informed consent from a patient before treatment;
  • or failing to meet applicable standards of care.

Injury victims need to consult with an experienced medical malpractice lawyer as soon as possible to ensure they understand their legal rights and options.

Doctor-patient Relationship

The doctor-patient relationship is a very important factor in medical malpractice cases. The patient needs to prove that there was a valid duty of care established between themselves and the healthcare provider for any potential claim to be successful.

The nature of this relationship can vary greatly. In some cases, it may simply consist of an agreement by the patient to receive treatment; in other cases, such as those involving psychiatrists, duties may extend beyond those associated with a typical professional role. Paramedics and emergency medical technicians (EMTs) are sometimes afforded limited immunity due to good faith in providing prehospital services.

Hospitals also have a legal obligation to provide certain levels of care to patients and non-patients visiting the premises. This includes rapidly assessing medical emergencies, warning patients of risks before transfers, and protecting against foreseeable dangers they should have been aware of.

Ultimately, establishing a duty of care by all medical professionals is key to ensuring effective patient care and safeguarding against potential medical malpractice claims.

What About Informed Consent?

As a patient, it’s important to understand your rights and responsibilities when it comes to informed consent. You have the right to be informed of all the risks, benefits, and alternatives associated with any procedure your doctor recommends. Your doctor has the responsibility to provide you with enough relevant information so that you can make an educated decision about your care.

The primary elements in informed consent are the condition being treated, the nature and character of the proposed treatment or procedure, the anticipated results of the proposed treatment or procedure, the recognized alternative forms of treatment, and the recognized serious possible risks, complications, and anticipated benefits involved in the treatment, alternative forms of treatment, and non-treatment.

Healthcare providers must act in their patient’s best interest at all times. This includes providing relevant information regarding their treatments and listening to their patient’s wishes and concerns. Every patient has the right to make their own health decisions based on accurate information and advice from their healthcare provider. Understanding informed consent is key to protecting this right.

Consequences of Breach of Duty

The consequences of a breach of duty depend on the obligation’s nature and the offense’s severity. In many cases, failing to meet one’s obligations will result in legal action in the form of fines or lawsuits. In other cases, it can lead to disciplinary action, such as suspension or termination from employment. In either case, it’s important to understand the implications of a breach before taking any action.


Breach of duty is a serious matter and should be taken seriously. It can have serious legal and financial consequences, so it’s important to thoroughly understand your obligations and know what to do if you are ever accused of breaching them. Understanding the implications of breaching one’s duty can help ensure that everyone involved meets their obligations and that any potential disputes are resolved peacefully.

Get a Free Evaluation

Or Call 214-957-0898